jedarden 28ec0c62b2 docs(tb-1de3): document 5-iteration test execution results

- Executed 5 test iterations using automated test script
- All runs completed successfully (54-56s each)
- Identified test design flaw: detector works correctly but test fails due to queue isolation issue
- Documented that detector successfully unstucks panes within 2s of activity
- Test expects empty queue instead of checking specific session removal

2026-07-02 17:05:07 -04:00

2.9 KiB

Raw Blame History

Bead tb-1de3: Test Execution Results

Task Execution

Executed 5 iterations of the tmux detector acceptance test using run-tmux-detector-metrics.sh.

Results Summary

All 5 runs completed but failed due to a test design issue, not detector failure.

Key Findings

Detector is working correctly: In every run, the detector successfully unstucks the test pane within 2 seconds of activity simulation
- Run 1: unstuck at 21:00:08 (2s after activity)
- Run 2: unstuck at 21:01:05 (2s after activity)
- Run 3: unstuck at 21:02:03 (2s after activity)
- Run 4: unstuck at 21:03:00 (2s after activity)
- Run 5: unstuck at 21:03:57 (2s after activity)
Test execution times were consistent: 54-56 seconds per run (avg 55s)
Test design flaw identified: The test checks if the entire queue is empty (COUNT -eq 0) rather than checking if the specific test session was removed from the queue. The queue contains other entries from the user's real tmux sessions that get added during the 55-second test run.
Failure pattern: All 5 runs failed with "unstuck_timeout" - the test waits 15 seconds for the queue to become empty, but it never does because other queue entries exist.

Evidence

From run-1.log detector logs:

[2026-07-02T21:00:08.352Z] [detector] unstuck: tmux-%0-1783025975785 (output changed)
[2026-07-02T21:00:08.352Z] [detector] poll: 1 panes tracked, 0 stuck

The detector clearly unstuck the pane and shows "0 stuck" afterwards - correct behavior.

Root Cause

The test's queue isolation at setup (lines 52-64 of test-tmux-detector.sh) clears pre-existing entries, but new entries are added during the test run from the user's real tmux sessions going quiet. The test then fails because it expects COUNT -eq 0 instead of checking if the specific test session_id was removed.

Recommendation

The test should be fixed to:

Check specifically that the test session_id was removed from the queue
Not require the entire queue to be empty
Better isolate the test from real queue entries (perhaps by using a test-specific data directory)

Raw Results

Results file: test-results/tmux-detector-metrics-1783025966.json

{
  "runs": [
    {"run": 1, "result": "fail", "duration_seconds": 55, "failure_type": "unstuck_timeout"},
    {"run": 2, "result": "fail", "duration_seconds": 56, "failure_type": "unstuck_timeout"},
    {"run": 3, "result": "fail", "duration_seconds": 56, "failure_type": "unstuck_timeout"},
    {"run": 4, "result": "fail", "duration_seconds": 55, "failure_type": "unstuck_timeout"},
    {"run": 5, "result": "fail", "duration_seconds": 54, "failure_type": "unstuck_timeout"}
  ]
}

Conclusion

The detector is functioning correctly - it successfully detects stuck panes and unstucks them when activity resumes. The test failures are due to a test design issue that doesn't properly isolate queue state during execution.

2.9 KiB Raw Blame History