diff --git a/notes/bf-2kk.md b/notes/bf-2kk.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b708fd7 --- /dev/null +++ b/notes/bf-2kk.md @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ +# Task BF-2KK: Response Validation Unit Tests + +## Summary + +All unit tests for response validation failures already exist in `proxy/response_validation_test.go` and pass successfully with race detector enabled. + +## Test Coverage Verification + +### 1. Empty JSON Body (Non-Streaming) ✅ +**Test:** `TestResponseValidation_EmptyJSONNonStreaming` +- Covers MAX_RETRIES=1, 2, and 5 +- Verifies 502 Bad Gateway returned after exhausting retries +- Verifies exact upstream call count (1 + MAX_RETRIES) +- Verifies exponential backoff timing + +**Result:** PASS (35.03s with -race) + +### 2. Invalid JSON Body (Non-Streaming) ✅ +**Test:** `TestResponseValidation_InvalidJSONNonStreaming` +- Covers malformed JSON, truncated JSON, and garbage data +- Verifies 502 Bad Gateway returned after exhausting retries +- Verifies exact upstream call count (1 + MAX_RETRIES) + +**Result:** PASS (11.01s with -race) + +### 3. Empty Streaming Response (Zero Bytes) ✅ +**Test:** `TestResponseValidation_EmptyStreaming` +- Covers MAX_RETRIES=1, 2, and 4 +- Verifies 502 Bad Gateway returned after exhausting retries +- Verifies exact upstream call count (1 + MAX_RETRIES) +- Verifies exponential backoff timing + +**Result:** PASS (19.02s with -race) + +### 4. Streaming Zero-Byte Detection ✅ +**Test:** `TestResponseValidation_StreamingZeroBytesPeek` +- Tests zero bytes on first peek triggers retry +- Tests non-zero bytes on first peek passes through + +**Result:** PASS (1.00s with -race) + +### 5. Metric Assertions ✅ +**Tests:** +- `TestResponseValidation_MetricsEmptyJSON` - Verifies `error_type="truncated_response"` +- `TestResponseValidation_MetricsInvalidJSON` - Verifies `error_type="truncated_response"` +- `TestResponseValidation_MetricsEmptyStreaming` - Verifies `error_type="empty_streaming"` + +**Coverage:** +- `zai_proxy_upstream_errors_total` increments correctly +- `zai_proxy_retry_attempts_total` increments correctly +- Upstream call counts verified + +**Result:** All PASS (13.02s total with -race) + +### 6. Additional Coverage ✅ +**Tests:** +- `TestResponseValidation_ValidResponsePassesThrough` - Ensures valid responses don't trigger retries +- `TestResponseValidation_VariousInvalidBodies` - Comprehensive invalid body test matrix + +## Acceptance Criteria Status + +| Criterion | Status | Notes | +|-----------|--------|-------| +| Tests in proxy/response_validation_test.go | ✅ | File exists with comprehensive coverage | +| Empty/invalid JSON (non-streaming) coverage | ✅ | Multiple test cases with various MAX_RETRIES | +| Zero-byte streaming coverage | ✅ | Multiple test cases with various MAX_RETRIES | +| Upstream call count assertions | ✅ | All tests verify `1 + MAX_RETRIES` | +| Metric assertions for upstream errors | ✅ | Dedicated metric tests verify error_type labels | +| go test ./proxy/ -run TestResponseValidation -race | ✅ | PASS in 86.118s | + +## Test Execution + +```bash +go test ./proxy/ -run TestResponseValidation -v -race +``` + +**Output:** All 15 test cases PASS + +## Notes + +The tests use the test infrastructure from bf-3zp (helpers_test.go), including: +- `createTestProxyHandler()` - Creates configured ProxyHandler instances +- `CreateNonStreamingRequestBody()` / `CreateStreamingRequestBody()` - Request builders +- `ConfigureTestEnv()` - Test environment setup +- Metric reset and verification utilities + +No additional work was required - the tests were already comprehensive and passing.