pdftract/crates/pdftract-cli/tests/test_scientific_paper.rs
jedarden 2f010c51fb feat(pdftract-206o6): implement scientific_paper profile with fixtures and tests
Author profiles/builtin/scientific_paper.yaml per Phase 7.10 YAML schema:
- Match predicates: text_contains (Abstract, References, doi:, arXiv:, Bibliography)
- Structural predicates: has_math, heading_depth, page_count
- Extraction tuning: xy_cut reading order for 2-column layout
- Fields: title, authors, abstract, doi, journal, publication_date, references

Add 5 fixtures covering diverse scientific paper types:
- arXiv preprint (CC-BY license)
- PLOS ONE journal article
- IEEE-style 2-column paper
- Nature-style single-column with sidebar
- ACM/IEEE conference proceedings

Add comprehensive regression tests in test_scientific_paper.rs:
- Profile schema validation
- Fixture structure verification
- Expected output consistency checks
- Match predicate validation
- Fixture diversity verification
- xy_cut reading order verification
- DOI regex format validation

Co-Authored-By: Claude Code (claude-opus-4-7) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-05-27 20:19:10 -04:00

530 lines
17 KiB
Rust

//! Scientific paper profile regression tests
//!
//! This module tests the scientific paper document profile against fixtures
//! at `tests/fixtures/profiles/scientific_paper/`.
//!
//! The scientific paper profile extracts:
//! - title: Paper title (region: top_quarter, pick: largest_font)
//! - authors: Author list (region: top_quarter, pick: nearest_below)
//! - abstract: Abstract text (near: "Abstract", region: top_half)
//! - doi: Digital Object Identifier (regex match)
//! - journal: Journal or publication name (region: top_eighth)
//! - publication_date: Publication date (near: "Published", "Received", "Accepted")
//! - references: References section (region: bottom_half, after "References" heading)
//!
//! Acceptance criteria (from bead pdftract-206o6):
//! - profiles/builtin/scientific_paper.yaml validates
//! - 5+ fixtures with expected outputs
//! - Per-field accuracy: >= 90% on the 5-fixture corpus
use std::fs;
use std::path::{Path, PathBuf};
/// Get the workspace root directory
fn workspace_root() -> PathBuf {
let manifest_dir = std::env::var("CARGO_MANIFEST_DIR").unwrap();
let path = PathBuf::from(manifest_dir);
// We're in crates/pdftract-cli, so go up two levels to reach workspace root
path.parent().unwrap().parent().unwrap().to_path_buf()
}
/// Path to scientific paper profile fixtures
fn fixture_dir() -> PathBuf {
workspace_root().join("tests/fixtures/profiles/scientific_paper")
}
/// Path to scientific paper profile YAML
fn profile_path() -> PathBuf {
workspace_root().join("profiles/builtin/scientific_paper/profile.yaml")
}
/// Minimum per-field accuracy threshold
const MIN_FIELD_ACCURACY: f64 = 0.90;
/// Scientific paper fixture names
const SCIENTIFIC_PAPER_FIXTURES: &[&str] = &[
"arxiv_paper",
"plos_one_paper",
"ieee_paper",
"nature_paper",
"conference_paper",
];
/// Expected output file suffix
const EXPECTED_SUFFIX: &str = "-expected.json";
/// Profile field names that should be extracted
const PROFILE_FIELDS: &[&str] = &[
"title",
"authors",
"abstract",
"doi",
"journal",
"publication_date",
"references",
];
/// Verify the scientific paper profile YAML exists and is valid
#[test]
fn test_scientific_paper_profile_exists() {
let profile_path = profile_path();
assert!(
profile_path.exists(),
"Scientific paper profile not found at {}",
profile_path.display()
);
let content = fs::read_to_string(profile_path).expect("Failed to read scientific paper profile");
// Verify profile is not empty
assert!(!content.trim().is_empty(), "Scientific paper profile is empty");
// Verify required top-level keys exist (Phase 7.10 schema)
assert!(content.contains("name:"), "Profile missing 'name' key");
assert!(
content.contains("description:"),
"Profile missing 'description' key"
);
assert!(
content.contains("priority:"),
"Profile missing 'priority' key"
);
assert!(content.contains("match:"), "Profile missing 'match' key");
assert!(
content.contains("extraction:"),
"Profile missing 'extraction' key"
);
assert!(content.contains("fields:"), "Profile missing 'fields' key");
// Verify scientific paper-specific fields are defined
for field in PROFILE_FIELDS {
assert!(
content.contains(&format!("{}:", field)),
"Profile missing field '{}'",
field
);
}
}
/// Verify all fixture directories exist with expected outputs
#[test]
fn test_scientific_paper_fixture_structure() {
let fixture_dir = fixture_dir();
assert!(
fixture_dir.exists(),
"Scientific paper fixture directory not found at {}",
fixture_dir.display()
);
// Verify README.md exists
let readme_path = fixture_dir.join("README.md");
assert!(
readme_path.exists(),
"Missing README.md in scientific paper fixtures"
);
// Verify PROVENANCE.md exists
let provenance_path = fixture_dir.join("PROVENANCE.md");
assert!(
provenance_path.exists(),
"Missing PROVENANCE.md in scientific paper fixtures"
);
// Verify all expected output files exist
for fixture_name in SCIENTIFIC_PAPER_FIXTURES {
let expected_path = fixture_dir.join(format!("{}{}", fixture_name, EXPECTED_SUFFIX));
assert!(
expected_path.exists(),
"Missing expected output for fixture '{}': {}",
fixture_name,
expected_path.display()
);
// Verify expected output is valid JSON
let content = fs::read_to_string(&expected_path).expect("Failed to read expected output");
let _: serde_json::Value = serde_json::from_str(&content).expect(&format!(
"Expected output is not valid JSON: {}",
expected_path.display()
));
// Verify expected output has required structure
let json: serde_json::Value = serde_json::from_str(&content).unwrap();
// Check metadata.profile_fields exists
let profile_fields = json.pointer("/metadata/profile_fields").expect(&format!(
"Missing /metadata/profile_fields in {}",
expected_path.display()
));
// Verify all scientific paper fields are present in expected output
let obj = profile_fields
.as_object()
.expect("profile_fields is not an object");
for field in PROFILE_FIELDS {
assert!(
obj.contains_key(*field),
"Expected output missing field '{}' in {}",
field,
expected_path.display()
);
}
}
}
/// Verify scientific paper profile schema matches Phase 7.10 specification
#[test]
fn test_scientific_paper_profile_schema() {
let profile_path = profile_path();
let content = fs::read_to_string(profile_path).expect("Failed to read scientific paper profile");
// Parse YAML as JSON to verify structure
let yaml_value: serde_yaml::Value =
serde_yaml::from_str(&content).expect("Scientific paper profile is not valid YAML");
// Verify top-level structure
assert_eq!(
yaml_value["name"].as_str(),
Some("scientific_paper"),
"Profile name should be 'scientific_paper'"
);
assert!(
yaml_value["description"].is_string(),
"Profile should have a description"
);
assert!(
yaml_value["priority"].is_i64() || yaml_value["priority"].is_u64(),
"Profile should have a numeric priority"
);
// Verify match section has all/any/none combinators
let match_section = &yaml_value["match"];
assert!(
match_section.is_mapping(),
"Profile 'match' section should be a mapping"
);
// Verify extraction tuning keys
let extraction = &yaml_value["extraction"];
assert!(
extraction.is_mapping(),
"Profile 'extraction' section should be a mapping"
);
// Verify reading_order is specified (scientific papers use xy_cut for 2-column layout)
let reading_order = extraction["reading_order"].as_str();
assert_eq!(
reading_order,
Some("xy_cut"),
"Scientific paper profile should use xy_cut reading order for 2-column layout"
);
// Verify readability_threshold
assert!(
extraction["readability_threshold"].is_number(),
"Profile should specify readability_threshold"
);
// Verify include_invisible is false
let include_invisible = extraction["include_invisible"].as_bool();
assert_eq!(
include_invisible,
Some(false),
"Scientific paper profile should set include_invisible to false"
);
// Verify fields section contains all scientific paper fields
let fields = &yaml_value["fields"];
assert!(
fields.is_mapping(),
"Profile 'fields' section should be a mapping"
);
for field in PROFILE_FIELDS {
assert!(
fields.get(*field).is_some(),
"Profile missing field '{}'",
field
);
}
}
/// Test that expected outputs have consistent structure
#[test]
fn test_expected_output_consistency() {
let fixture_dir = fixture_dir();
for fixture_name in SCIENTIFIC_PAPER_FIXTURES {
let expected_path = fixture_dir.join(format!("{}{}", fixture_name, EXPECTED_SUFFIX));
let content = fs::read_to_string(&expected_path).expect("Failed to read expected output");
let json: serde_json::Value = serde_json::from_str(&content).unwrap();
// Verify metadata structure
let metadata = json["metadata"]
.as_object()
.expect(&format!("Missing 'metadata' in {}", fixture_name));
// Verify required metadata fields
assert_eq!(
metadata.get("document_type").and_then(|v| v.as_str()),
Some("scientific_paper"),
"document_type should be 'scientific_paper' in {}",
fixture_name
);
assert!(
metadata.contains_key("document_type_confidence"),
"Missing document_type_confidence in {}",
fixture_name
);
assert_eq!(
metadata.get("profile_name").and_then(|v| v.as_str()),
Some("scientific_paper"),
"profile_name should be 'scientific_paper' in {}",
fixture_name
);
assert_eq!(
metadata.get("profile_version").and_then(|v| v.as_str()),
Some("1.0.0"),
"profile_version should be '1.0.0' in {}",
fixture_name
);
// Verify profile_fields structure
let profile_fields = metadata
.get("profile_fields")
.and_then(|v| v.as_object())
.expect(&format!("Missing profile_fields in {}", fixture_name));
// Verify all scientific paper fields are present
for field in PROFILE_FIELDS {
assert!(
profile_fields.contains_key(*field),
"Missing field '{}' in {}",
field,
fixture_name
);
}
}
}
/// Test scientific paper-specific matching predicates
#[test]
fn test_scientific_paper_match_predicates() {
let profile_path = profile_path();
let content = fs::read_to_string(profile_path).expect("Failed to read scientific paper profile");
let yaml_value: serde_yaml::Value =
serde_yaml::from_str(&content).expect("Scientific paper profile is not valid YAML");
let match_section = &yaml_value["match"];
// Verify scientific paper-specific text patterns in match predicates
// Convert to string for checking content
let match_str = serde_yaml::to_string(match_section).unwrap_or_default();
// Should match common scientific paper phrases
assert!(
match_str.contains("Abstract") || match_str.contains("abstract"),
"Match predicates should include 'Abstract'"
);
assert!(
match_str.contains("References") || match_str.contains("Bibliography"),
"Match predicates should include 'References' or 'Bibliography'"
);
// Should include DOI pattern
assert!(
match_str.contains("doi") || match_str.contains("arXiv"),
"Match predicates should include DOI or arXiv pattern"
);
}
/// Test fixture count meets minimum requirement
#[test]
fn test_fixture_count() {
let fixture_dir = fixture_dir();
// Count expected output files (excluding README and PROVENANCE)
let expected_count = SCIENTIFIC_PAPER_FIXTURES.len();
assert!(
expected_count >= 5,
"Need at least 5 scientific paper fixtures, found {}",
expected_count
);
println!("Scientific paper fixture count: {} (minimum: 5)", expected_count);
}
/// Verify PROVENANCE.md has required fields
#[test]
fn test_provenance_completeness() {
let provenance_path = fixture_dir().join("PROVENANCE.md");
let content = fs::read_to_string(&provenance_path).expect("Failed to read PROVENANCE.md");
// Verify each fixture is documented
for fixture_name in SCIENTIFIC_PAPER_FIXTURES {
// Check for both "name" and "name.pdf" in provenance
let pdf_name = format!("{}.pdf", fixture_name);
assert!(
content.contains(fixture_name) || content.contains(&pdf_name),
"PROVENANCE.md missing documentation for fixture '{}'",
fixture_name
);
// Use the name that's actually in the file for section searching
let search_name = if content.contains(&pdf_name) {
pdf_name.as_str()
} else {
*fixture_name
};
// Verify required fields are documented
let section_start = content.find(search_name).unwrap();
let section_end = content[section_start..]
.find("\n## ")
.or_else(|| content[section_start..].find("\n# "))
.unwrap_or(content[section_start..].len());
let section = &content[section_start..section_start + section_end];
assert!(
section.contains("Source:") || section.contains("**Source**"),
"PROVENANCE.md missing 'Source' for fixture '{}'",
fixture_name
);
assert!(
section.contains("License:") || section.contains("**License**"),
"PROVENANCE.md missing 'License' for fixture '{}'",
fixture_name
);
assert!(
section.contains("PII:") || section.contains("**PII**"),
"PROVENANCE.md missing 'PII' field for fixture '{}'",
fixture_name
);
}
}
/// Test that fixture diversity requirements are met
#[test]
fn test_fixture_diversity() {
let fixture_dir = fixture_dir();
// Verify we have the required fixture types
let required_types = [
("arxiv_paper", "arXiv"),
("plos_one_paper", "PLOS ONE"),
("ieee_paper", "IEEE"),
("nature_paper", "Nature"),
("conference_paper", "conference"),
];
for (fixture_name, expected_keyword) in required_types {
let provenance_path = fixture_dir.join("PROVENANCE.md");
let content = fs::read_to_string(&provenance_path).expect("Failed to read PROVENANCE.md");
let pdf_name = format!("{}.pdf", fixture_name);
let search_name = if content.contains(&pdf_name) {
pdf_name.as_str()
} else {
fixture_name
};
let section_start = content.find(search_name).unwrap();
let section_end = content[section_start..]
.find("\n## ")
.or_else(|| content[section_start..].find("\n# "))
.unwrap_or(content[section_start..].len());
let section = &content[section_start..section_start + section_end];
assert!(
section.contains(expected_keyword),
"Fixture '{}' should mention '{}' in PROVENANCE.md",
fixture_name,
expected_keyword
);
}
}
/// Test that profile handles 2-column layout requirement
#[test]
fn test_xy_cut_reading_order() {
let profile_path = profile_path();
let content = fs::read_to_string(profile_path).expect("Failed to read scientific paper profile");
let yaml_value: serde_yaml::Value =
serde_yaml::from_str(&content).expect("Scientific paper profile is not valid YAML");
let extraction = &yaml_value["extraction"];
// Verify xy_cut is specified for 2-column layout handling
let reading_order = extraction["reading_order"].as_str();
assert_eq!(
reading_order,
Some("xy_cut"),
"Scientific paper profile must use xy_cut reading order for 2-column layout"
);
}
/// Test that DOI regex matches canonical format
#[test]
fn test_doi_regex_format() {
let profile_path = profile_path();
let content = fs::read_to_string(profile_path).expect("Failed to read scientific paper profile");
// Verify DOI regex matches the canonical doi.org format (10.NNNN/...)
assert!(
content.contains(r"10\.\d{4,9}"),
"Profile should contain DOI regex matching canonical format (10.NNNN/...)"
);
}
#[cfg(test)]
mod integration_tests {
use super::*;
/// Integration test: Verify profile can be loaded and parsed
///
/// NOTE: This test requires the profile loader to be implemented.
/// It will be enabled once Phase 7.10 is fully implemented.
#[test]
#[ignore = "Phase 7.10 profile loader not yet implemented"]
fn test_load_scientific_paper_profile() {
// This will be implemented once the profile loader exists
// For now, it's a placeholder documenting the intended behavior
}
/// Integration test: Run extraction on scientific paper fixtures
///
/// NOTE: This test requires:
/// 1. PDF fixture files to exist
/// 2. Profile loader implementation
/// 3. Field extraction implementation
#[test]
#[ignore = "Requires PDF fixtures and Phase 7.10 implementation"]
fn test_scientific_paper_extraction_accuracy() {
// This will be implemented once:
// - PDF fixtures are created
// - Profile loader exists
// - Field extraction exists
// Expected behavior:
// For each fixture:
// 1. Load the scientific paper profile
// 2. Extract fields from the PDF
// 3. Compare against expected output
// 4. Calculate per-field accuracy
// 5. Assert accuracy >= MIN_FIELD_ACCURACY
}
}