diff --git a/notes/pdftract-2yl9j.md b/notes/pdftract-2yl9j.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a0836fb --- /dev/null +++ b/notes/pdftract-2yl9j.md @@ -0,0 +1,87 @@ +# pdftract-2yl9j: Heading Detection Implementation Verification + +## Task +Implement `classify_heading(block, page_body_median_font_size) -> bool` for Phase 4.4 heading detection. + +## Status: ALREADY IMPLEMENTED ✓ + +The heading detection functionality is already fully implemented in: +- **File:** `crates/pdftract-core/src/layout/line.rs` +- **Functions:** `classify_heading` (lines 666-703) and `classify_page_headings` (lines 705-722) + +## Implementation Details + +### `classify_heading` Function +```rust +pub fn classify_heading(block: &mut BlockInput, page_body_median_font_size: f32) -> bool +where + L: LineMetadata + Clone, +{ + // INV: threshold is strictly > 1.2 + let ratio = block.median_font_size / page_body_median_font_size; + let size_criterion = ratio > 1.2; + + // Single-line criterion + let line_count_criterion = block.lines.len() <= 1; + + if size_criterion && line_count_criterion { + block.kind = "heading".to_string(); + true + } else { + false + } +} +``` + +### Implementation Correctness + +**All requirements met:** +1. ✓ `classify_heading(block, page_body_median_font_size) -> bool` signature +2. ✓ Returns true when `block.median_font_size > 1.2 * page_body_median` +3. ✓ AND `block.lines.len() <= 1` +4. ✓ Sets `block.kind = "heading"` on positive + +**INV compliance:** +- Threshold is strictly `> 1.2`, not `>= 1.2` (line 692) + +## Acceptance Criteria Verification + +All acceptance criteria tests exist and pass: + +| Test Case | Expected | Status | +|-----------|----------|--------| +| 18pt block, body 12pt, 1 line | Heading (1.5 > 1.2) | ✓ PASS | +| 14pt block, body 12pt, 1 line | NOT (1.17 < 1.2) | ✓ PASS | +| 18pt block, 3 lines | NOT (too many lines) | ✓ PASS | +| 12pt block, body 12pt | NOT | ✓ PASS | + +### Additional Tests +- Threshold exactly 1.2: NOT heading (strict inequality) ✓ +- Empty block (0 lines): NOT heading ✓ +- 2-line block: NOT heading ✓ + +## Test Results + +Tests were run successfully with `cargo nextest run`: +``` +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 1/10) test_classify_heading_18pt_block_12pt_body_one_line_heading +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 2/10) test_classify_heading_empty_lines_not_heading +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 3/10) test_classify_heading_small_page_body_median +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 4/10) test_classify_heading_18pt_block_three_lines_not_heading +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 5/10) test_classify_heading_large_page_body_median +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 6/10) test_classify_heading_14pt_block_12pt_body_one_line_not_heading +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 7/10) test_classify_heading_threshold_exactly_1_2_not_heading +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 8/10) test_classify_heading_12pt_block_12pt_body_not_heading +PASS [ 0.006s] ( 9/10) test_classify_heading_two_lines_not_heading +PASS [ 0.006s] (10/10) test_classify_heading_threshold_just_above_1_2_is_heading +``` + +## Notes + +- The implementation uses string `kind` field (set to "heading") following the same pattern as `caption.rs` +- There are pre-existing compilation errors in other files (`header_footer.rs`, `table/output.rs`) that prevent the full test suite from running, but these are unrelated to the heading detection implementation +- The heading detection code itself compiles correctly and all tests pass when run in isolation + +## Conclusion + +The task is **already complete**. The `classify_heading` function is fully implemented, well-tested, and meets all acceptance criteria specified in the bead description and the plan (Phase 4.4, line 1702).