diff --git a/notes/pdftract-2um5s.md b/notes/pdftract-2um5s.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..91960f1 --- /dev/null +++ b/notes/pdftract-2um5s.md @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +# Verification Note: pdftract-2um5s (Phase 6.10: pdftract doctor coordinator) + +## Summary + +The pdftract doctor subcommand is fully implemented and functional. All 4 child task beads are closed: +- pdftract-1w5u1 (6.10.2: Output formats) - CLOSED +- pdftract-4q8cq (6.10.1: Check definitions) - CLOSED +- pdftract-4sky1 (6.10.3: Exit code policy) - CLOSED +- pdftract-653ah (6.10.4: Runbook integration) - CLOSED + +## Acceptance Criteria Status + +### PASS +- **All 4 child task beads closed**: YES +- **Module structure**: `crates/pdftract-cli/src/doctor/` contains `checks/` and `output/` submodules +- **No feature flag**: doctor ships in default-feature binary (verified with `cargo build --release`) +- **Exit code policy**: Verified - exits 0 for OK/WARN, exits 1 for FAIL (tested locally) +- **JSON output**: `--json` flag produces valid JSON (tested locally) +- **Features flag**: `--features` flag lists compiled features (tested locally) +- **Catch_unwind protection**: Every check wrapped in `run_check_safe()` (mod.rs:97-118) +- **Runbook integration**: docs/operations/manual-platform-smoke.md exists with doctor as Step 1 +- **Unit tests**: 12 doctor tests pass (cache_dir, binary, locale, memory, temp_dir, ulimit) + +### WARN (Minor structural note) +- **runbook.rs**: Acceptance criteria mentioned `runbook.rs` in module structure, but actual implementation (per child bead pdftract-653ah) used documentation integration instead. The runbook at docs/operations/manual-platform-smoke.md fully references doctor output with troubleshooting tables. + +## Verification Commands + +```bash +# Build +cargo build --release + +# Test basic doctor output +./target/release/pdftract doctor + +# Test JSON output +./target/release/pdftract doctor --json | jq . + +# Test features flag +./target/release/pdftract doctor --features + +# Run unit tests +cargo test --bin pdftract doctor + +# Verify runbook exists +ls -la docs/operations/manual-platform-smoke.md +``` + +## Child Beads Verification + +All 4 child beads verified as CLOSED: +```bash +bf show pdftract-1w5u1 # 6.10.2: Output formats - Status: closed +bf show pdftract-4q8cq # 6.10.1: Check definitions - Status: closed +bf show pdftract-4sky1 # 6.10.3: Exit code policy - Status: closed +bf show pdftract-653ah # 6.10.4: Runbook integration - Status: closed +``` + +## Plan Reference + +Phase 6.10 pdftract doctor (lines 2477-2532 in `/docs/plan/plan.md`) + +All critical tests from plan section 6.10 are implemented: +- Exit code 0 on OK/WARN, 1 on FAIL (line 2538-2539) +- Feature-gated checks show N/A in JSON (line 2543) +- catch_unwind protection for every check (INV-8) +- Sequential check execution with <10s budget + +## Conclusion + +The coordinator bead pdftract-2um5s is complete. All child work is integrated and functional. The minor deviation from acceptance criteria (runbook.rs vs docs integration) reflects the actual implementation approach taken by child bead pdftract-653ah, which produced comprehensive runbook documentation at docs/operations/manual-platform-smoke.md.