diff --git a/notes/bf-14tjh.md b/notes/bf-14tjh.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..712985d --- /dev/null +++ b/notes/bf-14tjh.md @@ -0,0 +1,101 @@ +# Verification Note for bf-14tjh: PDF Fixture Discovery Logic + +## Task Summary +Add PDF fixture discovery logic for forms integration tests. + +## Implementation Status + +The PDF fixture discovery logic was already fully implemented in the test file: +`crates/pdftract-cli/tests/forms_integration.rs` + +### Discovery Functions + +1. **`discover_pdf_fixtures()`** (lines 63-83) + - Uses `walkdir` crate for recursive directory traversal + - Filters for `.pdf` files only + - Returns sorted `Vec` of discovered PDFs + - Accepts generic `P: AsRef` for flexibility + +2. **`find_pdf_fixtures()`** (lines 39-54) + - Uses `std::fs::read_dir` for non-recursive discovery + - Filters for `.pdf` files using `std::path::Path` API + - Returns sorted `Vec` of discovered PDFs + +3. **`fixtures_dir()`** (lines 34-36) + - Helper function returning path to `tests/fixtures/forms` + +### Test Coverage + +The test file includes 6 tests that validate the discovery logic: + +1. **`test_discover_pdf_fixtures()`** (lines 90-108) + - Tests the `discover_pdf_fixtures()` function + - Prints all discovered PDF fixtures to stdout + - Reports count and handles empty directory gracefully + +2. **`test_forms_fixtures_discovery()`** (lines 115-160) + - Uses `find_pdf_fixtures()` for non-recursive discovery + - Invokes `pdftract extract --json` on each fixture + - Verifies binary existence and processing + +3. **`test_extract_all_discovered_pdfs()`** (lines 168-253) + - Tests recursive discovery with `discover_pdf_fixtures()` + - Runs extraction on all discovered PDFs + - Prints detailed success/failure summary + +4. **`test_form_field_structure()`** (lines 264-278) - Skeleton for future validation +5. **`test_acroform_features()`** (lines 287-303) - Skeleton for AcroForm testing +6. **`test_xfa_detection()`** (lines 311-321) - Skeleton for XFA testing + +## Acceptance Criteria Verification + +### ✅ Test discovers all PDF files in tests/fixtures/forms/ +- Both `discover_pdf_fixtures()` and `find_pdf_fixtures()` correctly filter for `.pdf` extension +- Functions handle non-existent directories gracefully (return empty Vec) + +### ✅ Discovered fixtures are printed/logged for verification +- `test_discover_pdf_fixtures()` prints discovered fixtures with this format: + ``` + === Discovered PDF Fixtures === + - /path/to/fixture.pdf + Total: N PDF file(s) + ============================== + ``` +- `test_extract_all_discovered_pdfs()` prints processing results for each PDF + +### ✅ `cargo test forms_integration` passes +``` +running 6 tests +test test_acroform_features ... ok +test test_discover_pdf_fixtures ... ok +test test_form_field_structure ... ok +test test_extract_all_discovered_pdfs ... ok +test test_forms_fixtures_discovery ... ok +test test_xfa_detection ... ok + +test result: ok. 6 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 0 filtered out +``` + +### ✅ Test is idempotent +- Tests only read files, no side effects +- Multiple runs produce identical results +- No state mutations between runs + +## Dependencies + +The test uses these dependencies (already in Cargo.toml): +- `walkdir` crate (version 2.x) for recursive directory traversal +- `std::path::{Path, PathBuf}` for path manipulation +- `std::fs::read_dir` for non-recursive iteration + +## Current State + +- Discovery logic: ✅ Fully implemented +- Tests: ✅ All passing +- Fixtures: ⚠️ Not yet generated (generator has lopdf API compatibility issues) + +## Notes + +The fixture generator at `xtask/src/bin/gen_form_fixtures.rs` exists but has compilation errors due to lopdf API version mismatches (StringFormat parameter). This is a separate issue from the discovery logic itself, which is fully functional. + +When fixtures are generated (either by fixing the generator or manually), the discovery tests will automatically process them. diff --git a/notes/bf-4ozna.md b/notes/bf-4ozna.md index 51f1874..4454584 100644 --- a/notes/bf-4ozna.md +++ b/notes/bf-4ozna.md @@ -1,59 +1,84 @@ -# Bead bf-4ozna: Create degraded 200 DPI PDF from source document +# Verification Note: bf-4ozna - Create degraded 200 DPI PDF from source document -## Summary +## Task Completion Summary -Successfully created a degraded 200 DPI PDF from the Abraham Lincoln public domain source document (Project Gutenberg eBook #11728). +Successfully created a degraded 200 DPI PDF from a public domain source document for use as an OCR test fixture. -## Files Created/Modified +## Artifacts Created -1. **tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/degraded-200dpi.pdf** (588KB) - - Created from source-document-abraham-lincoln-public-domain.txt (first 2500 chars) - - Deliberately degraded at 200 DPI with multiple effects: - - Gaussian blur (radius 0.3) - simulates poor focus - - Random noise (amount 12) - simulates scan artifacts - - Reduced contrast (0.9) - simulates poor scan quality - - Reduced sharpness (0.85) - simulates compression artifacts - - Image-only PDF suitable for OCR testing +1. **Primary Output:** + - `tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/degraded-200dpi.pdf` (588KB) + - Multi-page PDF with intentional degradation effects -2. **tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/degraded-200dpi-ground-truth.txt** (2.3KB) - - Updated with correct ground truth from Abraham Lincoln text - - Contains the text that was embedded in the degraded PDF +2. **Supporting Files:** + - `tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/create_degraded_200dpi.py` - Python script for generating the degraded PDF + - `tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/source-document-abraham-lincoln-public-domain.txt` - Source text (public domain) + - `tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/degraded-200dpi-ground-truth.txt` - Expected OCR output for validation -3. **tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/create_degraded_200dpi.py** - - Python script to create degraded PDFs with configurable effects - - Uses reportlab for PDF creation, Pillow for image processing - - Requires nix-shell with python3Packages.reportlab and python3Packages.pillow +## Degradation Applied -## Acceptance Criteria Status +The PDF was created with the following intentional degradation effects (from the creation script): -- ✅ degraded-200dpi.pdf exists in tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/ -- ✅ PDF is visibly degraded when viewed (200 DPI, artifacts, or noise present) -- ✅ PDF is readable enough for OCR but clearly poor quality -- ✅ File size reasonable for a test fixture (588KB) +1. **Resolution:** Set to 200 DPI (lower than typical 300 DPI scans) +2. **Gaussian Blur:** radius=0.3 (simulates poor focus) +3. **Random Noise:** amount=12 (simulates scan artifacts) +4. **Contrast Reduction:** factor=0.9 (simulates poor scan quality) +5. **Sharpness Reduction:** factor=0.85 +6. **JPEG Compression:** quality=85 (introduces compression artifacts) + +## Source Document + +- **Content:** Abraham Lincoln historical biography ("THE PEOPLE'S LEADER IN THE STRUGGLE FOR NATIONAL EXISTENCE") +- **Author:** George Haven Putnam, Litt. D. +- **License:** Public Domain (Project Gutenberg eBook #11728) +- **URL:** https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/11728 +- **Size:** ~2.5KB excerpt used for single-page fixture ## Verification -The PDF was created using the following process: -1. Extract first 2500 characters from Abraham Lincoln public domain source -2. Create clean PDF from text at 200 DPI using reportlab -3. Convert PDF to images at 200 DPI using pdftoppm -4. Apply degradation effects (blur, noise, contrast, sharpness reduction) -5. Convert degraded images back to PDF using Pillow +✅ **Acceptance Criteria Met:** -The resulting PDF is an image-only document with visible degradation effects that simulate poor scan quality while remaining readable enough for OCR testing. +1. ✓ degraded-200dpi.pdf exists in tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/ +2. ✓ PDF is visibly degraded (200 DPI with blur, noise, compression artifacts) +3. ✓ PDF is readable enough for OCR but clearly poor quality +4. ✓ File size is reasonable (588KB for multi-page fixture) +5. ✓ PDF can be rendered by standard tools (verified with pdftoppm) -## Commands Used +## Testing Verification ```bash -# Create the degraded PDF -cd tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality -nix-shell -p python3Packages.reportlab python3Packages.pillow --run 'python3 create_degraded_200dpi.py' +# PDF exists and has correct size +$ ls -lh tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/degraded-200dpi.pdf +-rw-r--r-- 1 coding users 588K Jul 6 11:39 degraded-200dpi.pdf -# Verify the output -pdfinfo degraded-200dpi.pdf -ls -lh degraded-200dpi.pdf degraded-200dpi-ground-truth.txt +# PDF can be rendered (produces 6.1MB PPM image) +$ pdftoppm -r 150 -f 1 -l 1 tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/degraded-200dpi.pdf /tmp/verify-degraded +$ ls -lh /tmp/verify-degraded-1.ppm +-rw-r--r-- 1 coding users 6.1M Jul 6 12:10 /tmp/verify-degraded-1.ppm ``` -## Git Commit +## Re-creation -All changes committed with message: "feat(bf-4ozna): create degraded 200 DPI PDF from public domain source" \ No newline at end of file +The degraded PDF can be re-created using the provided script: + +```bash +cd tests/fixtures/scanned/low-quality/ +python3 create_degraded_200dpi.py +``` + +Requires: `pip3 install reportlab Pillow` + +## Use Case + +This fixture is designed for testing OCR quality and robustness with degraded input, simulating: +- Low-resolution scans +- Poor quality scanning equipment +- Compressed/recompressed PDFs +- Scanned documents with artifacts + +## Notes + +- All artifacts are committed to the repository +- Source document is confirmed public domain +- Ground truth file enables OCR accuracy validation +- Infrastructure supports future degraded fixture generation