diff --git a/notes/miroir-cdo-phase1-final-verification.md b/notes/miroir-cdo-phase1-final-verification.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c24344a --- /dev/null +++ b/notes/miroir-cdo-phase1-final-verification.md @@ -0,0 +1,148 @@ +# Phase 1 (miroir-cdo): Core Routing — Final Verification Summary + +**Date**: 2026-05-09 +**Session**: Final verification of Phase 1 Core Routing implementation + +## Definition of Done Checklist + +### ✅ Router Correctness (plan §8) + +1. **Rendezvous assignment determinism**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_rendezvous_determinism`: Same (shard_id, nodes) → identical Vec + - `acceptance_determinism_1000_runs`: 1000 randomized runs, all deterministic + +2. **Minimal reshuffling on node add**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_minimal_reshuffling_on_add`: Adding 4th node moves ≤ 50% of shards + - `acceptance_reshuffle_bound_on_add`: 64 shards, 3→4 nodes → ≤ 32 edges differ + +3. **Uniform shard distribution**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_shard_distribution_64_3_rf1`: 64 shards / 3 nodes / RF=1 → 15-27 shards per node + - `acceptance_uniformity_64_shards_3_nodes_rf1`: Each node holds 15-27 shards + +4. **Top-RF placement stability**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_top_rf_stability`: Top-RF nodes change minimally on add/remove + - `acceptance_rf2_placement_stability`: RF=2 placement stable on node change + - `acceptance_reshuffle_bound_on_remove`: 4→3 nodes, ~RF × S / Ng edges differ + +5. **write_targets returns RG × RF nodes**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_write_targets_count`: Exactly RG × RF nodes returned + - `test_group_scoped_assignment`: One node from each replica group + +6. **query_group distributes evenly**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_query_group_distribution`: Round-robin distribution verified + +7. **covering_set returns one node per shard**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_covering_set_one_per_shard`: Exactly one node per shard + - `test_covering_set_replica_rotation`: Intra-group replica rotation works + +### ✅ Result Merger (plan §8) + +1. **Global sort by _rankingScore**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_global_sort_by_ranking_score`: Descending order verified + +2. **Offset/limit after merge**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_offset_and_limit_applied_after_merge`: Pagination works correctly + +3. **_rankingScore stripping**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_ranking_score_stripped_when_not_requested`: Strips when not requested + - `test_ranking_score_included_when_requested`: Includes when requested + +4. **_miroir_shard stripping**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_miroir_shard_always_stripped`: Always stripped + - `test_strip_all_miroir_reserved_fields`: All _miroir_* fields stripped + +5. **Facet aggregation**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_facet_counts_summed_across_shards`: Sums counts across shards + - `test_facet_filter_only_merges_requested_facets`: Filter works + +6. **estimatedTotalHits summation**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_estimated_total_hits_summed`: Correctly summed + +7. **processingTimeMs max**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_processing_time_max_across_shards`: Max taken correctly + +8. **Tie-breaking**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_tie_breaking_by_primary_key`: Primary key ascending for ties + +9. **Degraded mode**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_degraded_flag_when_shard_fails`: Flag set when shards fail + - `test_not_degraded_when_all_succeed`: Flag not set when all succeed + +10. **Stable serialization**: ✅ PASSED + - `test_stable_serialization_same_input_same_json`: BTreeMap ensures deterministic JSON + +### ✅ Topology (plan §2) + +- `topology.rs`: 100.00% line coverage +- All state transitions tested +- Write eligibility rules tested +- Group isolation tested + +### ✅ Scatter (plan §2) + +- `scatter.rs`: 100.00% line coverage +- Stub implementation for Phase 2 wiring + +## Coverage Report (2026-05-09) + +``` +Filename Regions Missed Regions Cover Functions Missed Functions Executed Lines Missed Lines Cover Branches Missed Branches Cover +----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +anti_entropy.rs 56 0 100.00% 7 0 100.00% 70 0 100.00% 0 0 - +config.rs 293 26 91.13% 30 5 83.33% 306 18 94.12% 0 0 - +config/advanced.rs 166 16 90.36% 32 2 93.75% 288 20 93.06% 0 0 - +config/load.rs 159 77 51.57% 9 2 77.78% 140 28 80.00% 0 0 - +config/validate.rs 86 27 68.60% 1 0 100.00% 108 46 57.41% 0 0 - +merger.rs 977 31 96.83% 49 4 91.84% 582 31 94.67% 0 0 - +migration.rs 721 163 77.39% 43 12 72.09% 467 104 77.73% 0 0 - +reshard.rs 455 47 89.67% 36 7 80.56% 324 34 89.51% 0 0 - +router.rs 1016 26 97.44% 60 1 98.33% 500 19 96.20% 0 0 - +scatter.rs 214 0 100.00% 11 0 100.00% 121 0 100.00% 0 0 - +score_comparability.rs 589 10 98.30% 32 0 100.00% 325 9 97.23% 0 0 - +task.rs 164 0 100.00% 16 0 100.00% 118 0 100.00% 0 0 - +topology.rs 776 0 100.00% 70 0 100.00% 421 0 100.00% 0 0 - +----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- +TOTAL 5672 423 92.54% 396 33 91.67% 3770 309 91.80% 0 0 - +``` + +**Overall `miroir-core` line coverage: 91.80%** (exceeds 90% requirement) + +## Test Results + +**Total tests run**: 151 +**Passed**: 151 +**Failed**: 0 +**Ignored**: 0 + +### Breakdown by module: +- **router.rs**: 26 tests passed +- **topology.rs**: 45 tests passed +- **merger.rs**: 22 tests passed +- **scatter.rs**: 6 tests passed + +## Key Implementation Details + +### Rendezvous Hashing (HRW) +- Uses `twox_hash::XxHash64` with seed 0 (matches Meilisearch Enterprise) +- Canonical order: `(shard_id, node_id)` - critical for determinism +- Tie-breaking: lexicographic by `node_id` for identical scores + +### Group Isolation +- Hashing scoped to intra-group node lists +- Prevents both replicas of a shard from landing in the same group +- `write_targets()` returns exactly `RG × RF` nodes, one from each group + +### Minimal Reshuffling +- Adding a node to a group moves ~1/(Ng+1) of that group's docs +- Top-RF placement changes minimally on add/remove + +### Result Merger +- Uses binary min-heap for efficient top-k selection +- BTreeMap for stable facet serialization +- Always strips `_miroir_*` reserved fields +- Conditionally strips `_rankingScore` based on client request + +## Status: COMPLETE ✅ + +All Phase 1 Core Routing requirements have been implemented and verified. +The foundation is ready for Phase 2 (write path) and Phase 3 (read path).