jedarden/miroir
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions

docs(bf-1zn8a): 3rd independent re-verification pass before close

Browse source 
Re-ran default-config and --features peer-discovery test suites fresh this
session; all claims in the coverage map re-confirmed. Comments [22]/[23]
already posted on bf-30m2j/bf-1zn8a. Closing the investigative step-1 bead
with acceptance_4 confirmed redundant and gaps (a/b/c) enumerated for child beads.

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
jedarden 2026-07-10 15:58:21 -04:00
parent 0af1ba460c
commit e9e7ed1612
1 changed files with 25 additions and 0 deletions
Show stats Download patch file Download diff file Expand all files Collapse all files

25
notes/bf-1zn8a.md
View file

@ -259,3 +259,28 @@ the required comments** (acceptance criterion 4) and **did not close**. This ses
Net: the disabled `acceptance_4` is confirmed **redundant**; the narrow real gaps are
(a) survivor-stability, (b) scale-up 3→4, (c) golden hash-vector — to be addressed by
child beads, not by rewriting the disabled test.
## Re-explore re-verification (2026-07-10, 3rd independent pass)
Bead re-dispatched for re-explore while still `in_progress`. Re-ran the core commands
fresh and re-confirmed every claim (no reliance on prior notes):
- `cargo test -p miroir-core mode_a` (default) → every binary `running 0 tests` /
`0 passed ... filtered out`. Three acceptance tests do **not** execute in default config.
- `cargo test -p miroir-core anti_entropy` (default) → 17 + 1 tests pass, **none** named
`test_mode_a_*` (feature-gated out).
- `cargo test -p miroir-core --features peer-discovery mode_a` → all three
`tests_mode_a_acceptance::*` execute and pass (`16 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored`).
- Re-confirmed root cause of the premise error: `lib.rs:41` gates the entire
`mode_a_coordinator` module behind `#[cfg(feature = "peer-discovery")]` and
`default = []` (`Cargo.toml:67`); `rendezvous_score` is private (`mode_a_coordinator.rs:112`).
- Re-confirmed CI gate runs the tests: `Makefile:8` and `k8s/argo-workflows/miroir-ci.yaml:140`
both use `cargo test --all --all-features`; `miroir-proxy` enables `peer-discovery`
(`crates/miroir-proxy/Cargo.toml:38`).
- Confirmed comments already posted: **[22]** on parent bf-30m2j, **[23]** on bf-1zn8a —
both match this re-verification.
Gaps (a)/(b)/(c) re-confirmed genuine by line (reassignment test captures only
`pod3_owned_initial` at :1704-1711 with no survivor-stability assert; only 3→2 scale-down;
no golden shard→owner vector). Conclusion unchanged: `acceptance_4` is redundant; address
the three narrow gaps via child beads. All bf-1zn8a acceptance criteria met; closing.